(This is republished from my old blog, which is gone now. Poor thing.)
I've been getting a lot of comments lately about homeschooling - ranging from, "I could Never do That!" to the not-so-veiled criticism of, "I could Never do That!" And both are usually followed by the question, "Why are you Doing That?!?" The longer I homeschool, and the more often I get this question, the more fatigued I find the answering. It's made me want to put together a tract on homeschooling - the reasons, answers to common objections, the joys and trials. Maybe I will, in my spare moments (BWAAAHAAHAHAHAAAW! Ahem, excuse me while I recover a moment.).
But, to be honest, the longer I homeschool, the easier it is for me to forget why I decided to do it in the first place. I need the tract so I have something to hand to those with honest questions, something that will give them more than my typical blank stare and "Ummmmm ...." By the time I remember what homeschooling is (a lifestyle!) and why I do it (Ummm ...), the topic of conversation has shifted, or the person speaking to me has decided that I am, indeed, insane and she really ought to be going now.
So, what is this homeschooling thing good for, anyway? Aren't I stunting my child's social development? Aren't I limiting his options for the future? Aren't I spending an awful lot of time doing something that others can do better, since they're trained in it; and an awful lot of money on something I could get, if I used the public schools, for free? Wouldn't I rather be - gasp - working?
Let me tell you a little story.
My oldest, St. Nick, was sharing our tiny backyard with his little brother and sister, while I did double-duty by watching them through the lens of my camera. Time passed, I got a few good shots, the kids played, and we were all getting cold. The snow had stopped for a day, leaving an abundance of mud, so my thoughts revolved around how to get the little ones inside and stripped to undies/diapers without getting a. all the mud in the house and b. the neighbors calling CPS on the woman who leaves her kids on the stoop in their underwear/diaper in April in Michigan. I had just managed to get two of the three inside when St. Nick Screamed from the back door, "MOMMY! I FOUND A BABY PORCUPINE!!!"
Had he said he'd found a dragon or a bag of gold or a brain in a jar, I'd have said, "Oh, that's nice dear," and gone on with washing little hands. But it is Michigan, and we do have porcupines, don't we? Except not usually in the city. But who knows? We have a skunk living in the alley, somewhere. So really, why not a porcupine?
I hurried to the back door only to stop in my tracks. Nicholas was pointing at something that appeared to be stuck in the mat on the back steps. "There, Mom! It's a baby porcupine!"
Why, it did look an awful lot like a porcupine - all black with little spines sticking out. But it also looked a bit creepy-crawly and the familiar hair-raising was happening on the back of my neck. There's nothing I hate more than creepy crawlies.
"I don't think that's a porcupine, Nicholas."
"Yes, it is! Look at it!"
"No, I think it's a ... a ... a caterpillar?"
He got down on his knees and peered at it. "I see lots of legs - it IS! It IS a caterpillar!"
And then it happened. This thing called homeschooling took over. My thoughts went from, "Ewww! How will I get it OFF my MAT!" to "Wow! A caterpillar! A HUGE, DISGUSTING, FURRY Caterpillar! It could turn into a MOTH! We could WATCH it! Wouldn't that be COOL?!?" I did not share these thoughts with St. Nick, however, because watching it would entail putting it in the house, which would entail finding a jar and filling it with leaves and - EWWWWWW - getting the huge, disgusting, furry caterpillar into the jar. Somehow. I merely said, "Don't squish it, maybe we can watch it some more, okay?"
"What kind is it?"
And you know what? I was just as curious as St. Nick. We rushed inside and went to Google and after looking at a handful of creepy-crawling, icky-yucky photographs, decided it was a type of Woolly Bear caterpillar. Well, mystery solved. Great homeschool moment!
I started on lunch while St. Nick, at top volume (the only volume he has, sadly), told his brother about the Super Cool Caterpillar he found on the steps that looks just like a porcupine and will turn into a MOTH!
At this point I was muttering, "School-flool, I don't need caterpillars in my house to homeschool." Every thought of getting that furry thing into a jar was making my breath catch. I Do Not Like insects, bugs, spiders of any sort. Even Ladybugs are a stretch. I can handle looking at them, but touching one is out of the question. Same goes for butterflies. A Woolly Bear caterpillar? Not a chance.
All through lunch I eyed a huge, seldom-used vase on the window ledge, I thought of how I could cover the top in plastic wrap, fix a rubber band around it, poke holes ... that would be such a lovely caterpillar home. We could watch it build a cocoon and emerge as something winged and wriggly. I wouldn't mind watching that - I've never seen it myself.
I got the vase down. I got the plastic wrap out. And finally, I asked St. Nick, "What do you think the caterpillar would like in his home?"
He nearly exploded with glee.
But I set down one rule. "You, Nicholas, you have to be brave and put the caterpillar in the vase yourself. Can you do that?"
He eagerly agreed. So long as he could use a spoon to pick it up.
While the little ones played in their food (the baby would have to have a bath after lunch because of this), St. Nick and I went outside, found the caterpillar still on the porch, put some soil and sticks and plants in the vase. And while I stood a good ten feet away, St. Nick expertly nudged the bug onto his gardening spade and dropped it in the habitat.
So, why do I homeschool? I have lots of reasons, and most of them have to do with education and family and what's best for St. Nick. But some of them are selfish - all about me. I homeschool because every day it stretches me in ways I never thought I'd be stretched, and every day I have the excitement and privilege and joy of learning, seeing, doing things that I never got to do when I was a child.
I never thought I'd have a caterpillar in my house, and I never thought I'd be as eager as my kids to see what the "little guy" was doing when I got up this morning. Here he is - smile for the camera baby! Isn't he cute?
